Showing posts with label 1989-05. Show all posts
Showing posts with label 1989-05. Show all posts

Monday, 31 March 2014

#131: Fine Particles--Part 1: The Dangers Of Incineration.

=======================Electronic Edition========================

RACHEL'S HAZARDOUS WASTE NEWS #131
---May 30, 1989---
News and resources for environmental justice.
------
Environmental Research Foundation
P.O. Box 5036, Annapolis, MD 21403
Fax (410) 263-8944; Internet: erf@igc.apc.org
==========
RACHEL-4CM = DIOXIN FOCUSED DIRECTORY
Remote Access Chemical Hazards Electronic Library.
Dioxinnz.com

========================Original Source========================

Incineration of anything, including garbage and hazardous chemical wastes, produces a kind of pollution that is uniquely dangerous to humans: fine particles.

In this series, we will first discuss the characteristics of fine particles, and later we will discuss health studies showing the consequences of breathing fine particles.

The process of incineration turns solids and liquids partly into gases and partly into tiny particles of soot or ash. As the gases rise in the smoke stack, they cool and some of the gas molecules come together to form additional fine particles. The resulting particles are exceedingly small when they are emitted into the environment. Scientists who study particles make a distinction between coarse (large) particles and fine (small) particles. Fine particles behave entirely differently from coarse particles and, as we will see, are much more dangerous to humans. Fine particles are also much more difficult and expensive to control. They are also invisible, so when they are not controlled, there is no way to know it except by monitoring with the proper instruments.

Coarse particles are those with a diameter larger than 2 micrometers (micrometers); fine particles are those with a diameter less than 2 micrometers. A micrometer (micrometers) is a millionth of a meter and a meter is about a yard. (An older term for micrometer is micron.)

Incinerators emit large numbers of particles, despite the best available control technology. Half of all the particles emitted will have a diameter less that 2 micrometers, and the majority of these will have a diameter of 0.3 micrometers.

It is difficult to imagine how small these particles are. To help understand what we're talking about, look at the dot over the letter i in this newsletter; that dot measures about 400 micrometers in diameter. You can fit 40,000 particles with a diameter of 2 micrometers on the dot. When the particles have a diameter of 0.3 micrometers, you can fit 1.7 million particles on the dot over the i.

Unfortunately, U.S. EPA [Environmental Protection Agency] regulations do not take into consideration the sizes of the particles emitted by an incinerator. For regulatory purposes, coarse particles are considered to be the same as fine particles, as if they were all equivalent. The regulations issued as part of the Resource Conservation and Recovery Act (RCRA) allow the emission of 0.08 grains per dry standard cubic foot of stack gas (or 180 milligrams per dry standard cubic meter). There are 437.5 grains in an ounce. 

Measurements show that half these particles will have diameters ranging from 2.5 down to 0.1 micrometers; of that half, a majority will have a diameter of 0.3 micrometers. If we assume that 25% are 2 micrometers, 25% are 1 micrometers, 35% are 0.3 micrometers and 15% are 0.1 micrometers in diameter, we can generalize about the fine particle emissions from an incinerator.

Each pound of fine particles emitted from an incinerator will consist of 140 quadrillion (1.4 x 1017) individual particles. A quadrillion is 1000 trillion. Over a year's time, an incinerator meeting the federal standards will legally emit anywhere from 10 to 1000 tons of fine particles, depending upon the size of the incinerator.

Breaking things into fine particles has the effect of vastly increasing their surface area. A single lump of waste weighing a pound (and having the same density as water) would have a surface area of about 44 square inches (a square 6.5" on a side), about the size of a large post card. But when that same pound is broken into fine particles, its combined surface area grows to 9900 square yards (approximately two football fields). This is important for several reasons: as these fine particles move upward in the smoke stack, they are immersed in a bath of gaseous chemicals that are cooling and are "looking" for a place to turn from a gaseous to a solid state. Fine particles, with their large surface area, provide an inviting place and so the surfaces of fine particles become covered with pollutants ("enriched" is the technical term for this) before they are released into the local air. In particular, fine particles become coated with toxic metals (lead, cadmium, arsenic, chromium, and zinc, and with sulfur and polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons--or with whatever else is in the smoke stack).

As the human body evolved throughout its long history, it adapted to the environment. One factor in the environment has always been dust, principally from dust storms. Dust from storms is larger than 5 micrometers in diameter and the human body evolved mechanisms for protection against such large particles. The hairs inside the nose, the mucous membranes lining the nose, throat and lungs, and even the shape of the throat, help to trap dust. As air is inhaled, the shape of the throat causes the air to swirl, so heavy dust particles are thrown outward by centrifugal force, where they strike the mucous-lined walls. As the tubes and passageways leading to the lungs twist and branch, they provide many opportunities for particles to collide with sticky walls and become trapped before they enter the lungs. Once trapped by mucous, coarse particles are coughed up and excreted.

Nature has gone to great lengths to protect the lungs because the deepest regions of our lungs provide places (called alveolar sacs, or alveoli) where oxygen passes into the blood and carbon dioxide passes out of the blood. The lungs provide a large surface area for contact with air, and thus with fine particles; the surface area of the alveoli is 65 square yards, which is larger than two tennis courts.

Thus, the deep regions of the lung provide very efficient, direct access to the blood stream and, by this means, to every part of the body. Unfortunately, humans now produce huge numbers of fine particles, and these are not caught by the body's protective mechanisms--they are simply too small. Fine particles pass easily into the deepest regions of the lungs, the alveoli, or alveolar sacs. There they remain indefinitely because no clearance mechanisms effectively remove them. Nature did not protect us against such particles, because none existed until very recently. Once lodged in the deep regions of the lung, fine particles, with their enormous surface area enriched with toxics, provide a particularly efficient means for delivering metals and organic pollutants directly into the blood stream. Their large surface area provides effective contact with moist tissue and the opportunity for dissolving or for other chemical reactions, putting pollutants directly into the victim's blood. Once in the circulatory system, toxics are then distributed throughout the body.

Fine particles have one other characteristic worthy of mention. They remain airborne for long periods of time and travel long distances--hundreds of miles, or ever farther. This occurs because they are so small and light that gravity does not pull them downward efficiently, so the slightest air current holds them aloft.

Furthermore, as we shall see, they are not removed from the atmosphere efficiently by rain. Therefore, for a long time after they are released into the environment, they remain available for humans to breathe in.

[To be continued.]

The best books on fine particles are those of the National Research Council, National Academy of Sciences: AIRBORNE PARTICLES (Baltimore, Md: University Park Press, 1979) and CONTROLLING AIRBORNE PARTICLES (Washington, Dc: National Academy of Sciences, 1980); a short summary appears in FINE PARTICULATE POLLUTION, a Report of the United Nations Economic Commission for Europe (London and NY: Pergamon Press, 1979). A good, though very technical, introduction is William Hinds, AEROSOL TECHNOLOGY; PROPERTIES, BEHAVIOR AND MEASUREMENT OF AIRBORNE PARTICLES (NY: John Wiley and Sons, 1982).

--Peter Montague, Ph.D.

Descriptor terms: particulates; air pollution; air quality; incineration; epa policies; rcra; emmissions;

Sunday, 30 March 2014

#128: Standards to Protect the Public.

=======================Electronic Edition========================

RACHEL'S HAZARDOUS WASTE NEWS #128
---May 9, 1989---
News and resources for environmental justice.
------
Environmental Research Foundation
P.O. Box 5036, Annapolis, MD 21403
Fax (410) 263-8944; Internet: erf@igc.apc.org
==========
RACHEL-4CM = DIOXIN FOCUSED DIRECTORY
Remote Access Chemical Hazards Electronic Library.
Dioxinnz.com
=======================Original Source========================

STANDARDS TO PROTECT THE PUBLIC.

Whenever someone wants to make some money and consequently dumps chemicals into a community's air or water, they are quick to point out that what they're doing "meets all state and federal standards." It is time we took a close look at the way standards have been set in this country.

The federal government has set air quality standards for only about a dozen pollutants. So the states have had to do it themselves. As of September, 1988, 37 states had set air quality standards based on a "threshold limit values" (TLVs) established by the American Conference of Governmental Industrial Hygienists (ACGIH). The ACGIH published its first list of TLVs in 1946 and has published updated lists every year since. The ACGIH began as a voluntary association of federal, state and local officials, but quickly its ranks swelled with academic researchers employed by industry, and by full-time industrial consultants.

In the early days, industry was the only source of data, and an unwilling source. In the United States, there was no federal regulation of general industry workplace hazards until 1971 (when the Occupational Safety and Health Act, OSHA, passed by Congress in 1970, went into effect). Consequently throughout the '40s, '50s and '60s, there was no independent source of information about the exposure of workers to chemicals and the consequences of those exposures (dose-response relationships). Industry was the only source of data on these matters and industry was under no obligation to tell what it knew. The head of the ACGIH TLV committee wrote in 1969, "The data are in short supply because industries either do not develop long-term studies, or if they do, more often than not, do not see fit to release the data in the open literature."

It is important to understand this concept of "open literature." Despite what you may have been taught in school, science does not produce "the" answer on any given question. The scientific method does not arrive at definitive answers, it arrives at conclusions that are always considered tentative, and it arrives at those conclusions through publication of different studies so that scientists can reach a consensus on what's right and what's wrong, what's true and what's not. As studies are published for all to see (in the "open literature"), different scientific groups criticize each other's methods and reasoning and conclusions; then they do new studies and publish their results; these in turn are criticized, and so a consensus develops that "yes, probably this chemical will not produce clinical symptoms of disease at x level of exposure for such and such a period of time under such and such conditions."

Studies that are not published in the open literature cannot be criticized. Their methods and reasoning cannot be scrutinized. In short they cannot participate in the scientific process that leads to consensus. Studies that are not published subvert the process of scientific inquiry which depends entirely upon public appraisal and reappraisal by practitioners searching for the always-elusive "truth."

In 1971, nearly all of the ACGIH's TLVs were adopted by the brand new Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA) as official workplace standards. At that point it was clear to any observer that the ACGIH would continue to influence federal workplace safety standards.

In 1970, the ACGIH TLV committee had added two Dow Chemical toxicologists to its ranks. In 1972, a Dupont industrial hygienist joined the committee. One of the Dow representatives, and the DuPont representative, became two of the four members of the new ACGIH committee on carcinogenic substances in 1972. The minutes of ACGIH meetings throughout the '70s show that industry representatives took on the task of setting safety standards for chemicals that their own firms produced. Specifically, the Dow representative had primary responsibility for establishing the TLVs for the following products manufactured by Dow, many of which are known carcinogens: vinyl chloride, vinylidine chloride, chloroform, methyl chloride, ethylene dichloride, ethylene dibromide, trichlorobenzene, dioxane, ethanolamine, dipropylene oxide methyl ether, styrene, ethylene glycol, dibromochloropropane, "Tordon," "Ruelene," "Dursban," and "Plictran." The DuPont representative had primary responsibility for setting safety standards for these DuPont products: dimethyl sulfate, "MOCA," lead chromate, formamide, dichloromonofluoromethane, "Lannate," "Karmex," and "Hyvar X."

We have selected only the grossest examples of conflict of interest affecting the ACGIH standardssetting process. Unfortunately, for the past 20 years or longer, the ACGIH has routinely used unscientific procedures, and secret industry data, to set workplace standards. A recent study of the ACGIH and its standards-setting processes concluded that "unpublished corporate communications were important in developing TLVs for 104 substances; for 15 of these, the TLV documentation was based solely on such information."

Thus, many standards initially set by the ACGIH, then adopted uncritically by the federal government, and now being adopted uncritically by state governments, were never established by a scientifically valid process. They were established by companysponsored scientists (some would call them indentured savants, others would give them the harsher name, biostitutes) whose goals were not to establish the truth, but were to press for levels of control that satisfied industry's needs. After all, controlling chemicals costs money, so really strict controls are expensive; laxer controls are cheaper, sometimes substantially cheaper.

Perhaps the more important point is that ACGIH standards were never intended as general environmental standards. The ACGIH specifically warns against using its published standards to set environmental standards because its TLVs pertain to the workplace, not to the general environment. Workers are different from the general public. Workers are in the prime years of life; they are healthy; they get a paycheck so presumably they are well-fed. Most of them are white, most of them are males. There are no babies in the workplace, no old people, no chronically ill people. Standards intended to protect only workers will definitely not adequately protect the general public. Nevertheless, state agencies often have no resources to develop their own standards, so they adopt ACGIH values, reduce them by an arbitrary amount (often a hundred-fold reduction) and declare them "safe" for the public. The "safety" of such standards is entirely dependent upon the original "safety" of the ACGIH standards and they were often set, as we have seen, under the influence of industry consultants to protect industry's interests.

The next time someone tells you their project is going to meet all state and federal standards, look into it very closely. You may be unpleasantly surprised.

The entire structure of pollution control developed in the U.S. over the past 20 years is dependent upon numerical standards. If the standards cannot be relied upon because they were established by unscientific processes, the entire framework of regulation is called into question.

Furthermore, if government hasn't the resources to test and evaluate new chemicals independently as they appear, this means that industry will continue to be the only source of available data in many cases. Thus it appears that the problem is structural and is not likely to be resolved easily. Something fundamental may have to change.

[To be continued.]

Get: Barry Castleman and Grace Ziem, "Toxic Pollutants, Science, and Corporate Influence," ARCHIVES OF ENVIRONMENTAL HEALTH, Vol. 44 (No. 2), March/April, 1989, pgs. 68, 127; and the same authors, "Corporate Influence on Threshold Limit Values." AMERICAN JOURNAL OF INDUSTRIAL MEDICINE, Vol. 13 (1988), pgs. 531-559. Free reprints available from Dr. Castleman, 1722 Linden Avenue, Baltimore, MD 21217.

--Peter Montague, Ph.D.

Descriptor terms: federal regulations; tlvs; air quality standards; osha; conflict of interest; acgih; conflict resolution;

Saturday, 29 March 2014

#127a: Counties With Superfund Dumps Also Have Excessive Cancers.

=======================Electronic Edition========================

RACHEL'S HAZARDOUS WASTE NEWS #127
---May 2, 1989---
News and resources for environmental justice.
------
Environmental Research Foundation
P.O. Box 5036, Annapolis, MD 21403
Fax (410) 263-8944; Internet: erf@igc.apc.org
==========
RACHEL-4CM = DIOXIN FOCUSED DIRECTORY
Remote Access Chemical Hazards Electronic Library.
Dioxinnz.com
=================================Original Source========================

A new study by federal EPA (U.S. Environmental Protection Agency) personnel reveals excessive cancer deaths in counties that have Superfund dumps (which we call "Superfund counties"), compared to counties that do not have such dumps ("non Superfund counties"). Counties that have Superfund dumps have excessive deaths from cancers of the lung, bladder, esophagus, stomach, large intestine, and rectum among white males; the same counties have excessive deaths from cancers of the lung, breast, bladder, stomach, large intestine and rectum among white females.

The study was conducted by two staff members at the EPA Health Effects Research Laboratory in Research Triangle, NC, and by a professor at the University of Miami School of Medicine in Miami, FL.

The study team used EPA data to identify 593 Superfund dump sites where there was laboratory-confirmed evidence of chemical contamination of groundwater supplies and where there was no alternate public water supply (in other words, where groundwater was the sole source of drinking water). The selected 593 dumps are located in 339 counties in 49 states. The study team used National Cancer Institute data on deaths among white males and females, 1970-1979, for 13 types of cancers to make the comparisons.

The excess cancers became apparent when the Superfund counties were compared to all non-Superfund counties, nationwide. The study team tried to match Superfund counties with other individual counties selected to have the same size white population over age 64, the same percent in-migration (people moving into the county during the study period), same median family income, and the same percentage of workers employed in manufacturing. However, 64 Superfund counties were unique (e.g., Los Angeles County, CA; Kings County, NY; Harris County, TX), so they abandoned the effort to find matching counties.

The study team then looked at geographical regions to see if they could identify a national patterns of disease. In EPA region 1 (Connecticut, Maine, Massachusetts, New Hampshire, Rhode Island, Vermont) they compared 23 counties with Superfund sites vs. 44 counties without Superfund sites; in the counties with Superfund sites they found increased deaths from female breast cancer. In EPA region 2 (New York and New Jersey) they compared 40 Superfund counties vs. 43 non-Superfund counties and they found no excessive cancer deaths in the Superfund counties, compared to the non-Superfund counties; in EPA region 3 (Delaware, Maryland, Pennsylvania, Virginia, West Virginia) the team studied 11 Superfund counties vs. 83 nonSuperfund counties and they found excessive deaths from bladder cancer in females, cancer of the large intestine among males and females, and cancer of the rectum in males; in the remaining EPA regions, 4-10, (which include all the rest of the U.S. except Alaska) they studied 241 Superfund counties vs. 2500 non-Superfund counties and they found excessive deaths from lung cancer in males and females, female breast cancer, and bladder, esophagal, and rectum cancer among males.

[We note that an earlier study of New Jersey, using different techniques, identified several cancers that occurred at excessive rates in municipalities having Superfund dumps, compared to municipalities lacking Superfund dumps. See G. Reza Najem and others, "Clusters of Cancer Mortality in New Jersey Municipalities; With Special Reference to Chemical Toxic Waste Disposal Sites and Per Capita Income." INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF EPIDEMIOLOGY, Vol. 14, No. 4 (1985), pgs. 528-537.]

EPA region 3 (Delaware, Maryland, Pennsylvania, Virginia, West Virginia) is the only geographical area where deaths from cancers of the gastrointestinal tract occurred among both men and women.

The researchers point out that their study does not prove that the Superfund dumps caused the observed patterns of disease. They note, for example, that the excess cancer deaths in Superfund counties may have occurred not because of direct contamination from the dumps, but because companies that produced the wastes may also have contaminated local food supplies, local air, and local water directly by emitting chemicals into the local environment. Another possibility is the Superfund dumps are located in heavily industrialized areas, or may be located in areas that differ from non-Superfund-site locations in other important but unknown ways. (Our experience with Superfund sites indicates that they tend to be located in sparsely populated rural areas, not heavily-industrialized urban areas. --Editors)

Get: Jack Griffith and others. "Cancer Mortality in U.S. Counties with Hazardous Waste Sites and Ground Water Pollution." ARCHIVES OF ENVIRONMENTAL HEALTH Vol. 44, No. 2 (March/April, 1989), pgs. 69-74. Free reprints available from: Jack Griffith, Ph.D., USEPA, Health Effects Research Laboratory (MD-55A), Research Triangle Park, NC 27711.

--Peter Montague, Ph.D.

Descriptor terms: cancer; health effects; superfund; landfilling; landfills; leaks; studies; epa; drinking water; water pollution; groundwater; gender; male; female; race; white; exposure