Showing posts with label Hormones. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Hormones. Show all posts

Saturday, 29 March 2014

#263: The Wingspread Statement--Part 1: Chemicals In Environment Affect Sexual Development In Wildlife. And Humans?

=======================Electronic Edition========================

RACHEL'S HAZARDOUS WASTE NEWS #263
---December 11, 1991---
News and resources for environmental justice.
------
Environmental Research Foundation
P.O. Box 5036, Annapolis, MD 21403
Fax (410) 263-8944; Internet: erf@igc.apc.org
==========
RACHEL-4CM = DIOXIN FOCUSED DIRECTORY
Remote Access Chemical Hazards Electronic Library.
Dioxinnz.com
=================================Original Source========================

Gradually during recent years a new body of knowledge has developed showing that some chemicals in food and water can mimic hormones and disrupt the development of living things like fish, birds, and mammals, including their sexual development.

In some cases, the effects on wildlife have been dramatic. For example, male herring gulls on Lake Ontario, exposed to DDT and other organochlorine compounds, developed female sex organs. Female-female pairing has been observed in herring gulls on Lake Michigan and on Santa Barbara Island, California. Because humans share the same basic mechanisms of growth and development as wildlife, an increasing number of scientists has become concerned that humans may already be affected without recognizing it.

In July of this year an international group of 21 scientists met at Wingspread in Racine, Wisconsin to assess what is known about these matters. They have now released a "consensus statement" containing information and opinions about the nature and possible causes of these problems. The five-page statement is called "Chemically Induced Alterations in Sexual Development: The Wildlife/Human Connection."

Background
Hormones are produced by the endocrine system--a bodily system consisting of specialized cells, tissues, and organs that create and secrete (usually into the blood) organic chemicals called hormones, which then regulate other kinds of cells in the body. Particular hormones only affect particular cells that contain "receptors" for those hormones. A small amount of a hormone attaches to a "receptor site" and the hormone-receptor pair then initiates a cascade of chemical changes, often with major and far-reaching consequences.

The endocrine system shares with the nervous system the job of adjusting the body's response to a changing external environment. The nervous system copes with environmental changes on an immediate basis, whereas the endocrine system copes with environmental changes on a sustaining basis. For example, when the body gets cold, the nervous system causes shivering, which raises the body's temperature. But each month it is the endocrine system that starts the human female menstrual cycle. In a developing fetus, it is the endocrine system that regulates cell division and organ differentiation. The endocrine system regulates pattern and timing of bird migration and of hibernation in mammals. Examples of endocrine glands in humans include the adrenal gland, pancreas, thyroid, pituitary, ovaries and testes.

The scientists gathered at Wingspread last July focused on the sex hormones--the androgens that make males look and act like males and the estrogens that make females look and act like females. The Wingspread Statement begins, "Many compounds introduced into the environment by human activity are capable of disrupting the endocrine system of animals, including fish, wildlife, and humans. The consequences of such disruption can be profound because of the crucial role hormones play in controlling development...."

"The following consensus was reached by participants at the workshop. "[1]. We are certain of the following:
"A large number of man-made chemicals that have been released into the environment, as well as a few natural ones, have the potential to disrupt the endocrine system of animals, including humans. Among these are the persistent, bioaccumulative, organohalogen compounds that include some pesticides (fungicides, herbicides, and insecticides) and industrial chemicals, other synthetic products, and some metals.[1]

"Many wildlife populations are already affected by these compounds. The impacts include thyroid dysfunction [impaired or abnormal functioning] in birds and fish; decreased fertility in birds, fish, shellfish, and mammals; decreased hatching success in birds, fish and turtles; gross birth deformities in birds, fish and turtles; metabolic abnormalities [impaired or abnormal use of energy, manufacture of tissue, or handling of resulting wastes] in birds, fish, and mammals; behavioral abnormalities in birds; demasculinization and feminization in male fish, birds, and mammals; defeminization and masculinization of female fish and birds; and compromised [impaired] immune systems in birds and mammals.

"The patterns of effects vary among species and among compounds. Four general points can nonetheless be made: (1) the chemicals of concern may have entirely different effects on the embryo, fetus, or perinatal [meaning "near the time of birth," from the 28th week of pregnancy through the first week of life, in humans] organism than on the adult; (2) the effects are most often manifested in offspring, not in the exposed parent; (3) the timing of exposure in the developing organism is crucial in determining its character and future potential; and (4) although critical exposure occurs during embryonic development [from conception through the end of the second month of pregnancy], obvious manifestations [effects] may not occur until maturity.

"Laboratory studies corroborate the abnormal sexual development observed in the field and provide biological mechanisms to explain the observations in wildlife.

"Humans have been affected by compounds of this nature, too. The effects of DES (diethylstilbesterol), a synthetic therapeutic agent, like many of the compounds mentioned [in footnote 1] are estrogenic [meaning they act like estrogen, a family of female sex hormones]. Daughters born to mothers who took DES now suffer increased rates of clear cell adenocarcinoma [cancer], various genital tract abnormalities, abnormal pregnancies, and some changes in immune responses. Both sons and daughters exposed in utero [while in the uterus] experience congenital anomalies of their reproductive system and reduced fertility. The effects seen in in utero DES-exposed humans parallel those found in contaminated wildlife and laboratory animals, suggesting that humans may be at risk to those same environmental hazards as wildlife."

The Wingspread Statement goes on: [2]. "We estimate with confidence that:

"Some of the developmental impairments reported in humans today are seen in adult offspring of parents exposed to synthetic hormone disruptors (agonists and antagonists) released in the environment. The concentrations of a number of synthetic hormone agonists and antagonists measured in the U.S. human population today are well within the range and dosages at which effects are seen in wildlife populations. [An agonist is a chemical that is not a hormone but mimics a natural hormone; an antagonist interferes with a natural hormone.] In fact, experimental results [in animals] are being seen at the low end of current environmental concentrations [in humans].

"Unless the environmental load of synthetic hormone disruptors is abated and controlled, large scale dysfunction at the population level is possible. The scope and potential hazard to wildlife and humans are great because of the probability of repeated and/or constant exposure to numerous synthetic chemicals that are known to be endocrine disruptors...."[3]. Current models predict that:

"... Both exogenous (external source) and endo-genous (internal source) androgens (male hormones) and estrogens (female hormones) can alter the development of brain function.

"Any perturbation [disturbance] of the endocrine system of a developing organism may alter the development of that organism: typically these effects are irreversible. For example, many sex-related characteristics are determined hormonally during a window of time in the early stages of development, and can be influenced by small changes in hormone balance. Evidence suggests that sex-related characteristics, once imprinted, may be irreversible."

The Wingspread statement then gives three reasons why these predictions are subject to "many uncertainties:" (1) effects of exposure of humans are not well understood, especially exposure of embryos; (2) data on reproductive problems in wildlife exist but data on behavior changes are not so readily available; (3) the potency of many synthetic [human-created] estrogenic chemicals is not well known.

The British publisher, Elsevier Applied Science, will publish a book on this subject by next fall. Until then, the best source of information is Theodora E. Colborn and others, GREAT LAKES GREAT LEGACY? available for $20.00 (plus $2.00 shipping) from: World Wildlife Fund, P.O. Box 4866, Hampden Post Office, Baltimore, MD 21211; phone (301) 516-6951.

For $3.00 plus stamped, self-addressed envelope, we can send you the Wingspread statement itself.

[More on this subject coming soon.] #264

--Peter Montague, Ph.D.

===============

[1] A footnote on page 1 of the Wingspread Statement says, "Chemicals known to disrupt the endocrine system include: DDT and its degradation products, DEHP (di(2-ethylhexyl)phthalate), dicofol, HCB (hexachlorobenzene), kelthane, kepone, lindane and other hexachlorocyclohexane congeners, methoxychlor, octachlorostyrene, synthetic pyrethroids, triazine herbicides, EBDC fungicides, certain PCB congeners, 2,3,7,8-TCDD and other dioxins, 2,3,7,8-TCDF and other furans, cadmium, lead, mercury, tributyltin and other organo-tin compounds, alkyl phenols (non-biodegradable detergents and anti-oxidants present in modified polystyrene and PVCs), styrene dimers and trimers, soy products, and laboratory animal and pet food products."

Descriptor terms: endocrine disruptors; racine; wi; wildlife; sexual development; endocrine system; fish; birds; herring gulls; mammals; humans; reproductive hazards; reproductive disorders; ddt; des; pesticides; herbicides; insecticides; fungicides; theodora colborn;

#264: The Wingspread Statement--Part 2: Major Challenge to 'Business as Usual'

=======================Electronic Edition========================

RACHEL'S HAZARDOUS WASTE NEWS #264
---December 18, 1991---
News and resources for environmental justice.
------
Environmental Research Foundation
P.O. Box 5036, Annapolis, MD 21403
Fax (410) 263-8944; Internet: erf@igc.apc.org
==========
RACHEL-4CM = DIOXIN FOCUSED DIRECTORY
Remote Access Chemical Hazards Electronic Library.
Dioxinnz.com
=================================Original Source========================

An international group of 21 scientists[1] met at Wingspread in Racine, Wisconsin in July, 1991 to discuss evidence that chemicals in the environment are causing changes in the sexual development of wildlife and conceivably in humans as well. (See RHWN #263.) The group produced a five-page "consensus statement."
Sexual development in wildlife, as in humans, is controlled by the endocrine system, a group of organs, tissues and cells that secrete hormones; the hormones interact with other cells, initiating chemical/biological reactions with far-reaching consequences. Male hormones are called androgens; female hormones are called estrogens.

It is now known that some chemicals disrupt the endocrine system. The Wingspread statement identifies the following: "Chemicals known to disrupt the endocrine system include: DDT and its degradation products [DDE and DDD], DEHP (di(2-ethylhexyl)phthalate), dicofol, HCB (hexachlorobenzene), kelthane, kepone, lindane and other hexachlorocyclohexane congeners [forms], methoxychlor, octachlorostyrene, synthetic pyrethroids, triazine herbicides, EBDC fungicides, certain PCB congeners [forms], 2,3,7,8-TCDD and other dioxins, 2,3,7,8-TCDF and other furans, cadmium, lead, mercury, tributyltin and other organo-tin compounds, alkyl phenols (non-biodegradable detergents and anti-oxidants present in modified polystyrene and PVCs), styrene dimers and trimers, soy products, and laboratory animal and pet food products."

In animals, and in humans, sexual characteristics are established at a particular point during development in the womb or egg. For example, Dr. Theodora Colborn of the World Wildlife Fund (Washington, DC) points out that a single dose of dioxin, administered to a pregnant rat at day 15 of the pregnancy--near the time when gender is established--results in demasculinization and feminization of male offspring.[2]

Samples of herring gulls from Lake Ontario collected in 1975 and 1976 showed cellular and anatomical changes in embryos and in newly hatched chicks that caused feminization of male chicks and overdevelopment of female reproductive organs. Elevated concentrations of DDE [a break down by product of DDT] and other residues were found in eggs from the same population. To test whether these sexual problems might be linked to the presence of the DDT, laboratory experiments were conducted in which Western gull eggs were injected with concentrations of DDT similar to those found in the Great Lakes environment. Male chicks became feminized, developing ovarian tissue and oviducts.[3]

What is becoming clear is that the older picture of chemical toxicity underestimates the number and kinds of effects that chemicals can have in fish, birds, and mammals. For decades, U.S. regulatory officials have focused their attention almost exclusively on cancer. Meanwhile, many of the chemicals that have been dumped into the environment, and are now coursing through food chains, cause many other detrimental effects besides cancer.

For example pesticides such as DDE, dieldrin, lindane, mirex, toxaphene, and PCBs, block communication between cells. Normal metabolism [energy use] and development of a cell may be disrupted because movement of nutrients, electrolytes, and hormones in and out of a cell is blocked by the presence of these poisons.[4]

Furans, benzo[a]pyrene, 2,3,7,8-TCDD [dioxin], DDE, dieldrin, HCB [hexachlorobenzene], lindane [beta-HCH], mirex, toxaphene, and PCBs induce enzyme activity. [Enzymes are large protein molecules that promote chemical activity in the body; the presence of particular enzymes makes possible particular chemical reactions that would not otherwise be possible.] When the enzyme activity is induced, normal products of the endocrine hormonal system can be released into the bloodstream. This can disrupt the role of steroid hormones, affecting growth and sexual maturation.[4]

The structure of DDT and DDE are, themselves, quite similar to estrogens and thus may mimic female hormones. In addition, DDE induces enzymes that break down male hormones. Under different circumstances, dioxin acts like an estrogen, or it may act as an anti-estrogen (what causes the same chemical to have opposite effects is not understood).[4]

At one Superfund site where data are available, humans are experiencing abnormalities of sexual development. At the Brio site south of Houston, Texas, where a housing development was built atop a chemical dump, girls 4 to 5 years old have developed pubic hair and enlarged breasts. One child (now four years old) was born without any genital organs; chromosome tests revealed that this is a male child, though he has a birth canal. This information, and other data about abnormal sexual development of children at the Brio site, is contained in a unique database of information that resulted from a health survey of the community by a local group (HELP) and by the Environmental Health Network (EHN) in Harvey, Louisiana.[5] Such surveys--providing an unusually valuable source of information about health problems near chemical dumps--are under way in several Superfund communities, looking for patterns of problems, including the kinds the Wingspread statement warns of.

The Wingspread statement presents a major new challenge to advocates of "business as usual." The participants in the conference represent 17 different fields of scientific inquiry. They have many thousands of data points on which they have based their conclusions. If they are right, we are all being exposed, on a daily basis, to chemicals that threaten out reproductive health, and the health of our offspring.

Because hormones and hormone disrupters do their work at extremely low concentrations, the only "safe" dose of an endocrine-system disrupter is zero. Thus any new sources of these chemicals should be aggressively discouraged while we figure out how to minimize exposure to the quantities of these chemicals already in the environment.

--Peter Montague, Ph.D.

===============

[1] Participants in the Wingspread meeting included the following individuals (whose institutional affiliations are given for identification purposes only): Dr. Howard A. Bern, Professor of Integrative Biology (emeritus) and Research Endocrinologist, University of California-Berkeley; Dr. Phyllis Blair, Professor of Immunology, University of California-Berkeley; Sophie Brasseur, Marine Biologist, Research Institute for Nature Management, Texel, The Netherlands; Dr. Theo Colborn, Senior Fellow, World Wildlife Fund, Washington, DC; Dr. Gerald R. Cunha, Developmental Biologist, University of California-San Francisco; Dr. William Davis, Research Ecologist, Environmental Research Laboratory, U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, Sabine Island, FL; Dr. Klaus D. Dohler, Director, Research, Development & Production, Phar-ma Bissendorf Peptide GmbH, Hannover, Germany; Glen Fox, Contaminants Evaluator, National Wildlife Research Center, Environment Canada, Quebec, Canada; Dr. Michael Fry, Research Faculty, Department of Avian Sciences, University of California-Davis; Dr. Earl Gray, Section Chief, Developmental and Reproductive Toxicology Division, Health Effects Research Laboratory, U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, Research Triangle Park, NC; Dr. Richard Green, Professor of Psychiatry in Residence, School of Medicine, University of California-Los Angeles; Dr. Melissa Hines, Assistant Professor in Residence, School of Medicine, University of California-Los Angeles; Timothy J. Kubiak, U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, East Lansing, MI; Dr. John McLachlan, Director, Division of Intramural Research, National Institute of Environmental Health Sciences, Research Triangle Park, NC; Dr. J.P. Myers, Director, W. Alton Jones Foundation, Charlottesville, VA; Dr. Richard E. Peterson, Professor of Toxicology and Pharmacology, School of Pharmacy, University of Wisconsin-Madison; Dr. P.J.H. Reijnders, Head, Section of Marine Mammology, Research Institute for Nature Management, Texel, The Netherlands; Dr. Ana Soto, Associate Professor, Tufts University School of Medicine, Boston, MA; Dr. Glen Van Der Kraak; Assistant Professor, University of Guelph, Ontario, Canada; Dr. Frederick vom Saal, Professor, Division of Biological Sciences, University of Missouri-Columbia; Dr. Pat Whitten, Assistant Professor, Department of Anthropology, Emory University, Atlanta, GA.

[2] David J. Hanson, "Dioxin Toxicity: New Studies Prompt Debate, Regulatory Action," C&EN [CHEMICAL & ENGINEERING NEWS] August 12, 1991, pg. 13.

[3] Theodora E. Colborn and others, GREAT LAKES GREAT LEGACY? (Washington, DC: Conservation Foundation, 1990), pg. 139.

[4] Theodora E. Colborn and others, cited above, pg. 142.

[5] For more information about the Brio site, contact HELP: 10904 Scarsdale Boulevard, M263, Houston, TX 77089; phone (713) 992-1867. For advice about health surveys, contact Linda King, Environmental Health Network, P.O. Box 1628, Harvey, LA 70058; phone (504) 362-6574.

Descriptor terms: endocrine disruptors; racine; wi; wildlife; sexual development; endocrine system; fish; birds; herring gulls; mammals; humans; reproductive hazards; reproductive disorders; ddt; des; pesticides; herbicides; insecticides; fungicides; theodora colborn; wwf; superfund; brio; ehn; environmental health network;

Friday, 28 March 2014

#310: The N.Y. Times Detoxifies Dioxin (Again)

=======================Electronic Edition========================

RACHEL'S HAZARDOUS WASTE NEWS #310
---November 5, 1992---
News and resources for environmental justice.
------
Environmental Research Foundation
P.O. Box 5036, Annapolis, MD 21403
Fax (410) 263-8944; Internet: erf@igc.apc.org
==========
RACHEL-4CM = DIOXIN FOCUSED DIRECTORY
Remote Access Chemical Hazards Electronic Library.
Dioxinnz.com
========================Original Source========================

During August and September U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) released drafts of 8 chapters of its long-awaited report on the dangers of dioxin. The agency then promptly convened a 4-day meeting of independent scientists September 22-25 to review and discuss the drafts.

The day after the meeting ended, the NEW YORK TIMES reported (Sept. 26, 1992, pg. 9) that "An independent panel of scientists concluded today that dioxin was not a large-scale cancer threat except to people exposed to unusually high levels of the toxic compound in chemical factories and from accidents."

The TIMES said, "The panel based its conclusions about the effects of dioxin on human health largely on four studies...."

The TIMES story said, "...the risk to average Americans exposed to dioxin, principally by eating beef, dairy products, chicken and fish, is lower than previously believed."

The TIMES reported that, "The risks, said several panelists, are largely confined to chemical workers and people exposed to high levels of dioxin from industrial accidents. They said the levels of dioxin ordinarily found in the environment had not been shown to be dangerous to people."

The TIMES went on, "Scientists have known for a long time that laboratory animals are apparently much more sensitive to the dioxin molecule than people for reasons that are not well understood, and newer studies have shown that trout, salmon, and some species of birds also are very sensitive."

The TIMES concluded, "In separate interviews, several panelists said today that they did not consider the levels of dioxin in most Americans, about 5 parts per trillion in fat, to be an important health hazard."

In sum, the NEW YORK TIMES led its readers to believe that a panel of independent scientists reviewed four studies and concluded, apparently by consensus, that dioxin is only a danger to the health of heavily-exposed chemical workers and victims of rare accidents, and even for them the only danger is cancer; that existing levels of dioxin in the environment are not dangerous to people; that the risks of dioxin are lower than previously believed; that laboratory animals and some wildlife may be at risk but this has little to do with humans because humans--for reasons unknown--seem to be uniquely unaffected by low doses of dioxin.

The TIMES put this comforting story on the wire and many U.S. newspapers picked it up. The result was a nation-wide press blitz saying dioxin is basically harmless to humans. For example, the DETROIT NEWS reprinted the TIMES story, then capped it off Sept. 29 with an editorial,"The End of Dioxin Hysteria?" which concluded, "But the fact that dioxin has turned out to be something of a non-issue where humans are concerned suggests the religious zeal with which some environmentalists are trying to close down the chemical industry deserves to be greeted with extreme skepticism."

Is this the last word on dioxin? It's not a threat to human health; levels found in the environment today are of little concern; the risks used to seem worse than they seem today; and the risks are limited to cancer among chemical factory employees. Is that what EPA spent 18 months and untold millions of dollars to find out?

It seems not. Other reporters and participants in the four-day meeting--including top EPA officials who called the meeting--came away with views and information almost 180 degrees out of sync with what the NEW YORK TIMES reported. On October 9, Erich W. Bretthauer, EPA's Assistant Administrator for Research and Development, sent a memo to EPA chief William Reilly giving Reilly his own views on what EPA has learned so far about dioxin. In his memo, Bretthauer made seven points, each of which was either contradicted, or missed entirely, by the TIMES:
1. To understand the risks of dioxin, we should consider a broad range of health effects, not just cancer, Bretthauer told Reilly. 
2. Dioxin has been observed to cause certain non-cancer effects in animals by disrupting the body's endocrine system (glands and tissues that control bodily functions via chemical messengers called hormones). These endocrine effects include reproduction, behavior of offspring, and changes in the immune system. "Some data suggest that these effects may be occurring in people at body burden levels that can result from exposures at, or near, current background," Bretthauer told Reilly. In other words, the amount of dioxin already present in the environment, and in the bodies of Americans, is at, or close to, levels that, in animals, cause hormone shifts, reproductive disorders, changes in behavior, and immune system damage. 
3. Recent studies indicate that dioxin causes cancer in humans; these studies need to be evaluated further and then EPA needs to form a new official position about the cancer hazard to humans. 
4. Additional compounds besides dioxin (for example, some types of PCBs) have dioxin-like effects and should be included in EPA's reassessment of the hazards of dioxin. 
5. There is insufficient data to develop a model that will allow us to predict the cancer hazards to humans from low-level exposure to dioxin. During the next 3 to 5 months, government studies may provide the needed data. 
6. The available data seem to indicate that dioxin will cause cancer in humans in proportion to the exposure--high doses will cause many cancers, lower doses will cause fewer cancers, and the only dose that is risk-free is zero. In other words, the so-called "linear hypothesis" of cancer causation appears to hold true in the case of dioxin, though this is not certain. 
7. Risks from existing background levels of dioxin in the general population need to be "carefully considered."
The WALL STREET JOURNAL (Oct. 16, 1992, pg. B9) summarized Bretthauer's memo this way: "Data reviewed by an independent scientific panel suggest that the danger from dioxin may be broader and more serious than previously thought, according to an internal Environmental Protection Agency memo."

The business journal, ENVIRONMENT REPORTER [ER] (Oct. 2, 1992, pg. 1504), offered its own coverage of the Sept. 22-25 meeting. The basis of ER's story was an interview with William H. Farland, director of the EPA Office of Health and Environmental Assessment, the man in charge of the EPA's reassessment of dioxin. Farland summarized the four-day meeting by saying dioxin is "a major health threat," and that the draft report on dioxin is "unlikely to ease public concern over dioxin."

Farland said that "scientists at the recent meeting reported a host of non-carcinogenic effects at very low dose levels--near background levels--as well as the ability to cause cancer in humans at high doses," 

ENVIRONMENT REPORTER said.
In sum, EPA's scientific reassessment of dioxin--which is based on several thousand studies of dioxin--isn't over yet, but so far the scientific evidence is showing dioxin to be a worse problem than formerly believed. The reassessment was initiated by EPA chief Reilly 18 months ago in response to complaints by the paper and chlorine industries, who charged that EPA's regulation of dioxin was too strict because low doses of dioxin are harmless. These industries argued that there is a "threshold," an amount of dioxin below which no effects will occur. EPA's scientific reassessment of dioxin has, so far, substantiated EPA's original view of dioxin, that it is a potent toxin for which there is no observable threshold. Furthermore, the reassessment has added a host of new concerns, which were discussed at length during the four-day meeting--concerns about disruption of the reproductive system, harm to the immune system, and behavioral changes in offspring of dioxin-exposed parents.

The really big news from the meeting was the revelation that these endocrine-system effects in animals are observable at body burdens similar to the body burdens in Americans today. If this view is upheld in the next few weeks as scientists continue to review the available data, it will mean that any addition of dioxin to the environment will be adding to an already-unacceptable situation. This would provide a scientific foundation for a demand that "zero discharge" be adopted as the basis for control of dioxin. William Farland nearly said as much in his interview with ER: "We have to be very cautious about any additions of dioxin to the environment. We must be very concerned about these high background levels of dioxin and what they may mean for human health."

Industries that emit dioxin into the environment--paper producers, waste incinerators, metal smelters, and herbicide producers and users--are feeling tremendous pressure to curtail emissions, and the pressure seems likely to increase.

Newspapers, of course, are dependent upon paper for their existence and they have a material interest in 
keeping paper prices low. According to the WALL STREET JOURNAL, the paper industry has already spent over a billion dollars trying to control dioxin.

The NEW YORK TIMES, which has a history of odd reporting on dioxin (see RHWN #248, #249, #275), received at least three letters to the editor complaining about its misleading coverage of the September meeting--two of them from scientists who participated in the meeting and who objected strongly to the TIMES's reporting. The TIMES also received a letter from a consultant to the incineration industry who said it was "comforting" to learn that the dioxin found now in the bodies of Americans is "less toxic than previously assumed." The TIMES did not print either of the letters from the scientists but did print the letter from the incineration consultant, who argued that automobiles are the leading source of dioxin. This point of view, which is no doubt comforting to the incineration industry, and to the paper and newspaper industries, is almost certainly wrong. 

We will provide more details next week.#311

--Peter Montague, Ph.D.

Descriptor terms: epa; dioxin; incineration; health; pulp and paper industry; dioxin reassessment; birth defects; ny times; carcinogens; cancer; wall street journal; automobiles;

#270: EPA'S Dioxin Reassessment--Part 2: Dioxin Damages Human Immune System

=======================Electronic Edition========================

RACHEL'S HAZARDOUS WASTE NEWS #270
---January 29, 1992---
News and resources for environmental justice.
------
Environmental Research Foundation
P.O. Box 5036, Annapolis, MD 21403
Fax (410) 263-8944; Internet: erf@igc.apc.org
==========
RACHEL-4CM = DIOXIN FOCUSED DIRECTORY
Remote Access Chemical Hazards Electronic Library.
Dioxinnz.com
========================Original Source========================

U.S. Environmental Protection Agency [EPA] is presently reassessing the dangers of dioxin, one of the most toxic chemicals ever tested on laboratory animals. As a result of animal tests, EPA has declared only exceedingly small amounts of dioxin "safe" for the human food supply. Americans eat food routinely containing roughly 10 to 100 times more dioxin than EPA considers safe. [SEE RHWN #269.]

No one makes dioxin intentionally, but many industries create dioxin as a byproduct of their main activity. Industries that emit dioxin into the environment (paper, plastics, chemicals, and solid waste incinerators) are being sued for their emissions by citizens claiming harm from exposure, and one industry--paper--faces billions of dollars in lawsuits.

Partly to please the paper industry, and partly because there were new scientific findings worth considering, EPA chief William Reilly announced a year-long dioxin reassessment to begin in April, 1991.

Now, nine months into the year-long process, EPA scientists responsible for parts of the reassessment have begun talking openly about new findings that make dioxin seem as bad as, or worse than, EPA used to think.
For two decades dioxin has baffled toxicologists. They are used to seeing cancer-causing chemicals that predominantly cause cancer in one organ or another--like asbestos, which chiefly affects the lungs, or benzene, which chiefly affects the blood-forming cells, causing leukemia. But dioxin seems to cause cancer in many organs, raising the general level of cancer in a population without causing a huge increase in any one type of cancer. In addition, dioxin causes certain toxic effects in one species and other effects in another species. Likewise, dioxin at low doses causes one kind of illness, and at higher doses it causes different illnesses. Only recently have EPA scientists concluded that this puzzling pattern occurs because dioxin acts like an "environmental hormone." Hormones are potent natural chemicals that send messages via the bloodstream, turning on and off chemical switches throughout the body, creating an array of effects in different organs. Dioxin behaves this way. Hormones are present in the body in tiny amounts, yet they can trigger huge changes in various bodily systems. For example, it is hormones that trigger the different stages of growth in a fetus, and that cause young humans to go through puberty.

New Information

EPA chief William Reilly was right--there IS new information about dioxin. But it won't be reassuring to the paper industry. On the contrary, two studies of workers exposed to dioxin, published during the past year, have shown unmistakable increases in cancers of several types. A study of 5172 American workers revealed a cancer rate 46% above the norm.[1] Likewise, a study of 1583 German workers revealed a cancer rate 39% above the norm; among German workers 20 years on the job, the rate was 82% above the norm, and among the most heavily exposed Germans workers, the cancer rate was three times the norm.[2] Notably, among female German workers, the risk of breast cancer was doubled. Whereas a year ago one might have argued whether dioxin had ever been shown to cause cancer in humans, now such arguments are only voiced by the kind of people who say it still isn't proven that cigarettes cause lung cancer.

Linda Birnbaum, one of the scientists conducting EPA's reassessment of dioxin, says these two studies have convinced her that dioxin causes cancer in humans, at least at relatively high exposures. But, she told SCIENCE NEWS (January 11, 1992, pgs. 24-27.), she has an even greater concern about dioxin: "I'm very concerned that much lower exposure to dioxin may result in adverse health effects that are very subtle and difficult to detect." She was talking about dioxin's impact on the immune system.

The immune system is an exceedingly complex network of organs, cells, and chemical secretions (hormones) that react to preserve health in the face of a vast array of hostile microorganisms and toxicants that our bodies encounter every day. The immune system fights against common colds, influenza, and the body's own cells that go haywire and start to multiply uncontrollably (a definition of cancer).

A degraded immune system leaves the body less able to defend itself against hostile forces in the natural environment. Dioxin attacks the immune system.

EPA's dioxin reassessment will "focus much greater attention on toxicological data revealing TCDD's [dioxin's] reproductive, developmental, and immunotoxic effects," says SCIENCE NEWS. Immunotoxic means toxic to the immune system. Furthermore, "This document [EPA's draft reassessment][ will also establish TCDD as the first pollutant to be regulated on the basis of toxicity observed at the cellular level."

This is one reason why the dioxin controversy is being followed so carefully by industry and by environmentalists. It promises to set precedents in the way chemicals are regulated in the future. In the past, chemicals were considered harmless if they caused no "clinical" damage (damage your family doctor might detect). Now, with the dioxin reassessment, evidence of chemical changes inside individual cells is being considered important to a person's well being.

"So far, studies in mice suggest that dioxin's immunotoxic punch occurs in extremely low doses and may well be more important than cancer in determining dioxin's primary health risk," says Birnbaum."

To study TCDD's toxicity to the immune system, researchers use mice, whose immune systems model those of humans. For example, EPA researchers have measured how well TCDD-treated mice withstand the influenza virus. Mice pre-treated with TCDD readily die after exposure to a quantity of virus that rarely kills healthy mice.

Naturally, it would be very difficult to detect such effects in people. If people exposed to unusually high levels of dioxin, say from a solid waste incinerator, had damaged immune systems and consequently experienced various illnesses, no one might ever suspect dioxin as a cause.

People might question whether some of dioxin's low-level effects represent real harm to people, but "...few people will contend that suppression of the immune system is not an adverse health effect," Birnbaum told 

SCIENCE NEWS.

Unlike hormones, which remain in the body only a few hours, dioxin has a half-life in the body of seven years. At the end of one half-life, half the initial dioxin remains. What this means is that dioxin has, relatively, a very long half-life in the body, unlike the hormones that it mimics, so it stays around to play havoc with the body's chemical systems year after year. "Thus one TCDD [dioxin] molecule can continuously disrupt normal cell physiology," says SCIENCE NEWS, citing work by well-known dioxin researcher Thomas A. Gasiewicz at the University of Rochester (NY) Medical School. EPA's Birnbaum, and Michael Holsapple, a well-known di-oxin researcher at the Medical College of Virginia, say studies of humans at Times Beach, Missouri, and of Vietnam veterans, were essentially bungled. Holsapple says, "If I were to take mice and ask the same [research] questions that are routinely asked of the populations of Times Beach or in the Ranch Hand study [of Vietnam vets exposed to dioxin-contaminated herbicide], I would come up with a very nebulous picture [of dioxin's immunotoxicity]," says Holsapple. "But when we ask different questions [in mice], we can certainly show very strong effects on the immune response," he says.

Is there a threshold for dioxin's damage to the human body? Is there a level of dioxin below which no effects can be observed? George Lucier of the National Institute of Environmental Health Sciences in Research Triangle, North Carolina, has been asking this question in his laboratory. His data show no evidence of any threshold. "My data might not prove that a threshold doesn't exist," he told SCIENCE NEWS, "but there's also no evidence of any thresholds." In other words, any amount of dioxin does some damage, according to Lucier's findings. This means the only safe amount is zero.

This conclusion is not what the paper industry wanted to hear when its executives urged William Reilly to initiate EPA's dioxin reassessment. As the reassessment reaches its draft stages early this summer, we'll have new measures of the potency not only of dioxin, but also of industry's muscle in a contest with unwelcome scientific conclusions.

For all of us, much is riding on the outcome.

{Also see - Dioxin Reassessment--Part 1: #269}

--Peter Montague, Ph.D.

===============

[1] Marilyn Fingerhut and others, "Cancer Mortality in Workers Exposed to 2,3,7,8-tetrachlorodibenzo-P-dioxin," NEW ENGLAND JOURNAL OF MEDICINE Vol. 324 (1991), pgs. 212-218.

[2] A. Manz and others, "Cancer Mortality Among Workers in Chemical Plant Contaminated With Dioxin," THE LANCET Vol. [338] (October 19, 1991), pgs. 959-964.

Descriptor terms: dioxin: dioxin reassesment: immune systems: evironmental protection agency: cancer: paper industry: william reilly