Showing posts with label Paper industry - Dioxin. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Paper industry - Dioxin. Show all posts

Friday, 28 March 2014

#275: Dioxin Detoxification Campaign Exposed

=======================Electronic Edition========================

RACHEL'S HAZARDOUS WASTE NEWS #275
---March 4, 1992---
News and resources for environmental justice.
------
Environmental Research Foundation
P.O. Box 5036, Annapolis, MD 21403
Fax (410) 263-8944; Internet: erf@igc.apc.org
==========
RACHEL-4CM = DIOXIN FOCUSED DIRECTORY
Remote Access Chemical Hazards Electronic Library.
Dioxinnz.com
========================Original Source========================

A remarkable front-page story in the WALL STREET JOURNAL February 20 confirmed that the paper and chlorine industries have waged a successful two-year campaign to bamboozle the nation's media about the toxicity of dioxin, and that U.S. Environmental Protection (EPA) fell for it too.

The point of the campaign was to salvage the paper industry, which uses 15% of all the chemical industry's chlorine output, and which is facing billions of dollars in lawsuits brought by citizens claiming damages from dioxin released from paper mills.

The JOURNAL's story ("How Two Industries Created a Fresh Spin on the Dioxin Debate") by Chicago-based staffer Jeff Bailey, describes a bald-faced campaign by the American Paper Institute (API) and the Chlorine Institute to "revisit" the scientific evidence that dioxin is a potent carcinogen.

The JOURNAL says, "The paper industry scored its first major public-relations success in 1990, when paper companies arranged to challenge the findings of the most influential dioxin study ever done. That study, reported in 1978 by Richard Kociba, a Dow Chemical Co. pathologist, was done on 485 white rats, whose food was spiked with dioxin. Dr. Kociba found a strong link to cancer: a daily dose of billionths of a gram led to tumors."

To counteract the Kociba study, API hired five pathologists and brought them to a Maryland Lab in March, 1990, where for two days they reviewed Dr. Kociba's rat slides under a microscope. The pathologists voted on each slide--were they looking at a cancer tumor or at a "benign" tumor? At the end of the two days, they had voted for 50% fewer cancer tumors than Dr. Kociba had observed 12 years earlier. Robert A. Squire, the pathologist who oversaw the recount, told the JOURNAL, "There was't much unanimity. This was an uncertain finding."

Nevertheless API managed to ignore the uncertainties. Based on its "new evidence" that dioxin is less potent than previously believed, API wrote stern letters to the Food and Drug Administration (FDA), to President Bush's science adviser, and to William Reilly, chief of EPA. API told EPA, "All of the Agency's analyses are now out of date in light of the significant new evidence showing that the risks of dioxin has been overstated."
The JOURNAL does not say so, but almost immediately the API's publicity machine began cranking out the "news" that dioxin was no longer considered very dangerous. May 31, 1990 the WASHINGTON POST (pg. A3) surprised the world with the headline, "Scientists Temper Views on Cancer-Causing Potential of Dioxin." The story, by Malcolm Gladwell, said, "Dioxin--the chemical that forced the evacuation of Love Canal, sparked a wave of lawsuits over Agent Orange and became notorious as the most potent carcinogen ever tested--may be far less dangerous than previously imagined, according to new scientific evidence." Gladwell went on, "Enough experts have joined the revisionist chorus that some scientists consider a softening of the government's stance toward the chemical inevitable." Gladwell's "chorus" consisted of quotations from four scientists. Gladwell neglected to mention that three of them were consultants paid by the paper industry.

With the WASHINGTON POST on board, the "detoxify dioxin" campaign was rolling.

The JOURNAL goes on: "Next the Chlorine Institute... arranged to bring three dozen of the world's foremost experts on dioxin to a conference at the Banbury Center [on Long Island in October, 1990]." The JOURNAL continues, "Also present was George L. Carlo, a scientist but not widely regarded as a dioxin expert...." "Carlo is not a scientist with a long history of dioxin credentials," Dr. George Lucier of the National Institutes of Environmental Health Sciences told the JOURNAL. The JOURNAL goes on: "Why was Carlo there? Though described as a 'conference participant' by the Chlorine Institute, he was actually the industry's $150-an-hour observer. Based on his account, the institute would later circulate reports that the scientists had reached an important consensus...."

Carlo's account, which the Chlorine Institute immediately circulated widely to journalists and to state regulatory officials, said that the scientists at Banbury had reached consensus that dioxin does no harm until a certain threshold of exposure is reached. In other words, Carlo claimed--and the Chlorine Institute sent out press statements claiming--that the Banbury meeting had reached agreement that there is some amount of dioxin that is safe. The JOURNAL continues, "The institute's statement, however, didn't accurately reflect what had happened at the conference....A Chlorine Institute official concedes its representations about the conference were a 'botched publicity effort.' The institute now agrees there was no conference consensus on whether a dioxin threshold exists."

However, before the world had a chance to learn that the Chlorine Institute was playing fast and loose with the facts, the Institute's disinformation about Banbury was fed to William Reilly, chief of EPA, who fell for it. Citing the Banbury "consensus," in early 1991 Reilly ordered his scientific staff to officially "reassess" the toxicity of dioxin.

The paper industry got help from other friends in high places. In May, 1991, a highly-placed federal health official just three years shy of retirement announced that dioxin was much less toxic than previously believed. Dr. Vernon Houk, Director of the Center for Environmental Health and Injury Control, announced that he believed dioxin was only "a weak carcinogen." Houk's statements formed the "news hook" that allowed the NEW YORK TIMES to climb on board with its own page-one story August 15, 1991: "U.S. Officials Say Dangers of Dioxin Were Exaggerated." With the POST, the TIMES, Houk and Reilly all speaking with one voice, the "detoxify dioxin" campaign was clearly succeeding.

But with the publication of the WALL STREET JOURNAL's story Feb. 20, the campaign has come unraveled. The scientist in charge of EPA's reassessment, Peter Preuss, is quoted in the JOURNAL saying that Vernon Houk's statements "misled" the public about the dangers of dioxin. Other scientists on EPA's reassessment team say dioxin seems to be just the tip of a nasty iceberg--that other chemicals in the environment seem to share dioxin's ability to interfere with the human reproductive and immune systems. If we all carry dioxin in our bodies at an average of 7 ppt [parts per trillion], when you add furans and PCBs [polychlorinated biphenyls], our average body burden of "dioxin equivalents" may be as high as 100 ppt.[1] This is not good news. And it means that any additional dioxins or furans added to the environment would worsen a situation that it already unacceptable from a public health perspective. Knowing this, anyone who intentionally emits dioxins into the environment seems like a logical target for a barrage of lawsuits.

It is now clear that dioxin lawsuits can devastate an industry. For example, the WALL STREET JOURNAL reported February 7, 1992 (pg. A5), that the Georgia-Pacific Co.--a major paper producer--recently lost two dioxin lawsuits in which juries awarded $4.2 million to residents living downstream of its paper mill on the Leaf River in New Augusta, Mississippi. Georgia-Pacific has been named in 159 additional lawsuits filed by 8209 plaintiffs who claim they suffered emotional harm after eating fish contaminated with dioxins from the Georgia-Pacific Plant. Furthermore, according to the JOURNAL, Georgia-Pacific's insurance carriers say their policies don't cover damages in lawsuits like these. Georgia-Pacific has now sued Aetna Life & Casualty and seven other insurance companies in Mississippi federal court asking a judge to force the insurance carriers to pay. No matter how that lawsuit comes out, someone is likely to have to pay tens, or perhaps hundreds, of millions of dollars--and this represents the problems of only one mill owned by one company.

As the JOURNAL commented, "Other paper companies are likely taking note of Georgia-Pacific's setbacks. International Paper Co. and Champion International Corp. are among those who faced similar suits." Likely they are.

Other industries are also likely watching the paper's industry's dioxin troubles proliferate.

For example, cement kilns don't produce dioxin in substantial amounts until they start burning hazardous waste as a fuel, which many kilns have recently started doing. It is interesting to note reports that George Carlo has recently been hired as a consultant by a trade association representing the cement kiln industry.

When will dioxin lawsuits against cement kilns and against municipal solid waste incinerators begin? And how big will the jury awards be in these cases? When your community is deciding whether to install a solid waste incinerator,[2] or whether to tolerate a cement kiln seeking permission to burn hazardous waste, ask your community leaders, "Have you been reading the WALL STREET JOURNAL lately?"

--Peter Montague, Ph.D.

===============

[1] David J. Hanson, "Dioxin Toxicity: New Studies Prompt Debate, Regulatory Action," C&EN [Chemical & Engineering News] Aug. 12, 1991, pgs. 7-14.

[2] A good discussion of dioxin emissions from solid waste incinerators appears in Donald J. Lisk, "Environmental Implications of Incineration of Municipal Solid Waste and Ash Disposal," SCIENCE OF THE TOTAL ENVIRONMENT Vol. 74 (1988), pgs. 39-66, and in the articles Lisk cites in his footnotes.

Descriptor terms: dioxin; detoxification; paper industry; chlorine industry; epa; api; dow chemical; cancer; malcolm gladwell; william reilly; georgia-pacific; cement kilns; incineration;

#270: EPA'S Dioxin Reassessment--Part 2: Dioxin Damages Human Immune System

=======================Electronic Edition========================

RACHEL'S HAZARDOUS WASTE NEWS #270
---January 29, 1992---
News and resources for environmental justice.
------
Environmental Research Foundation
P.O. Box 5036, Annapolis, MD 21403
Fax (410) 263-8944; Internet: erf@igc.apc.org
==========
RACHEL-4CM = DIOXIN FOCUSED DIRECTORY
Remote Access Chemical Hazards Electronic Library.
Dioxinnz.com
========================Original Source========================

U.S. Environmental Protection Agency [EPA] is presently reassessing the dangers of dioxin, one of the most toxic chemicals ever tested on laboratory animals. As a result of animal tests, EPA has declared only exceedingly small amounts of dioxin "safe" for the human food supply. Americans eat food routinely containing roughly 10 to 100 times more dioxin than EPA considers safe. [SEE RHWN #269.]

No one makes dioxin intentionally, but many industries create dioxin as a byproduct of their main activity. Industries that emit dioxin into the environment (paper, plastics, chemicals, and solid waste incinerators) are being sued for their emissions by citizens claiming harm from exposure, and one industry--paper--faces billions of dollars in lawsuits.

Partly to please the paper industry, and partly because there were new scientific findings worth considering, EPA chief William Reilly announced a year-long dioxin reassessment to begin in April, 1991.

Now, nine months into the year-long process, EPA scientists responsible for parts of the reassessment have begun talking openly about new findings that make dioxin seem as bad as, or worse than, EPA used to think.
For two decades dioxin has baffled toxicologists. They are used to seeing cancer-causing chemicals that predominantly cause cancer in one organ or another--like asbestos, which chiefly affects the lungs, or benzene, which chiefly affects the blood-forming cells, causing leukemia. But dioxin seems to cause cancer in many organs, raising the general level of cancer in a population without causing a huge increase in any one type of cancer. In addition, dioxin causes certain toxic effects in one species and other effects in another species. Likewise, dioxin at low doses causes one kind of illness, and at higher doses it causes different illnesses. Only recently have EPA scientists concluded that this puzzling pattern occurs because dioxin acts like an "environmental hormone." Hormones are potent natural chemicals that send messages via the bloodstream, turning on and off chemical switches throughout the body, creating an array of effects in different organs. Dioxin behaves this way. Hormones are present in the body in tiny amounts, yet they can trigger huge changes in various bodily systems. For example, it is hormones that trigger the different stages of growth in a fetus, and that cause young humans to go through puberty.

New Information

EPA chief William Reilly was right--there IS new information about dioxin. But it won't be reassuring to the paper industry. On the contrary, two studies of workers exposed to dioxin, published during the past year, have shown unmistakable increases in cancers of several types. A study of 5172 American workers revealed a cancer rate 46% above the norm.[1] Likewise, a study of 1583 German workers revealed a cancer rate 39% above the norm; among German workers 20 years on the job, the rate was 82% above the norm, and among the most heavily exposed Germans workers, the cancer rate was three times the norm.[2] Notably, among female German workers, the risk of breast cancer was doubled. Whereas a year ago one might have argued whether dioxin had ever been shown to cause cancer in humans, now such arguments are only voiced by the kind of people who say it still isn't proven that cigarettes cause lung cancer.

Linda Birnbaum, one of the scientists conducting EPA's reassessment of dioxin, says these two studies have convinced her that dioxin causes cancer in humans, at least at relatively high exposures. But, she told SCIENCE NEWS (January 11, 1992, pgs. 24-27.), she has an even greater concern about dioxin: "I'm very concerned that much lower exposure to dioxin may result in adverse health effects that are very subtle and difficult to detect." She was talking about dioxin's impact on the immune system.

The immune system is an exceedingly complex network of organs, cells, and chemical secretions (hormones) that react to preserve health in the face of a vast array of hostile microorganisms and toxicants that our bodies encounter every day. The immune system fights against common colds, influenza, and the body's own cells that go haywire and start to multiply uncontrollably (a definition of cancer).

A degraded immune system leaves the body less able to defend itself against hostile forces in the natural environment. Dioxin attacks the immune system.

EPA's dioxin reassessment will "focus much greater attention on toxicological data revealing TCDD's [dioxin's] reproductive, developmental, and immunotoxic effects," says SCIENCE NEWS. Immunotoxic means toxic to the immune system. Furthermore, "This document [EPA's draft reassessment][ will also establish TCDD as the first pollutant to be regulated on the basis of toxicity observed at the cellular level."

This is one reason why the dioxin controversy is being followed so carefully by industry and by environmentalists. It promises to set precedents in the way chemicals are regulated in the future. In the past, chemicals were considered harmless if they caused no "clinical" damage (damage your family doctor might detect). Now, with the dioxin reassessment, evidence of chemical changes inside individual cells is being considered important to a person's well being.

"So far, studies in mice suggest that dioxin's immunotoxic punch occurs in extremely low doses and may well be more important than cancer in determining dioxin's primary health risk," says Birnbaum."

To study TCDD's toxicity to the immune system, researchers use mice, whose immune systems model those of humans. For example, EPA researchers have measured how well TCDD-treated mice withstand the influenza virus. Mice pre-treated with TCDD readily die after exposure to a quantity of virus that rarely kills healthy mice.

Naturally, it would be very difficult to detect such effects in people. If people exposed to unusually high levels of dioxin, say from a solid waste incinerator, had damaged immune systems and consequently experienced various illnesses, no one might ever suspect dioxin as a cause.

People might question whether some of dioxin's low-level effects represent real harm to people, but "...few people will contend that suppression of the immune system is not an adverse health effect," Birnbaum told 

SCIENCE NEWS.

Unlike hormones, which remain in the body only a few hours, dioxin has a half-life in the body of seven years. At the end of one half-life, half the initial dioxin remains. What this means is that dioxin has, relatively, a very long half-life in the body, unlike the hormones that it mimics, so it stays around to play havoc with the body's chemical systems year after year. "Thus one TCDD [dioxin] molecule can continuously disrupt normal cell physiology," says SCIENCE NEWS, citing work by well-known dioxin researcher Thomas A. Gasiewicz at the University of Rochester (NY) Medical School. EPA's Birnbaum, and Michael Holsapple, a well-known di-oxin researcher at the Medical College of Virginia, say studies of humans at Times Beach, Missouri, and of Vietnam veterans, were essentially bungled. Holsapple says, "If I were to take mice and ask the same [research] questions that are routinely asked of the populations of Times Beach or in the Ranch Hand study [of Vietnam vets exposed to dioxin-contaminated herbicide], I would come up with a very nebulous picture [of dioxin's immunotoxicity]," says Holsapple. "But when we ask different questions [in mice], we can certainly show very strong effects on the immune response," he says.

Is there a threshold for dioxin's damage to the human body? Is there a level of dioxin below which no effects can be observed? George Lucier of the National Institute of Environmental Health Sciences in Research Triangle, North Carolina, has been asking this question in his laboratory. His data show no evidence of any threshold. "My data might not prove that a threshold doesn't exist," he told SCIENCE NEWS, "but there's also no evidence of any thresholds." In other words, any amount of dioxin does some damage, according to Lucier's findings. This means the only safe amount is zero.

This conclusion is not what the paper industry wanted to hear when its executives urged William Reilly to initiate EPA's dioxin reassessment. As the reassessment reaches its draft stages early this summer, we'll have new measures of the potency not only of dioxin, but also of industry's muscle in a contest with unwelcome scientific conclusions.

For all of us, much is riding on the outcome.

{Also see - Dioxin Reassessment--Part 1: #269}

--Peter Montague, Ph.D.

===============

[1] Marilyn Fingerhut and others, "Cancer Mortality in Workers Exposed to 2,3,7,8-tetrachlorodibenzo-P-dioxin," NEW ENGLAND JOURNAL OF MEDICINE Vol. 324 (1991), pgs. 212-218.

[2] A. Manz and others, "Cancer Mortality Among Workers in Chemical Plant Contaminated With Dioxin," THE LANCET Vol. [338] (October 19, 1991), pgs. 959-964.

Descriptor terms: dioxin: dioxin reassesment: immune systems: evironmental protection agency: cancer: paper industry: william reilly